Building friendships in Stardew Valley is one of the most rewarding aspects of the game, and Penny is a villager many players adore. Gifting is key to deepening your bond with Penny. To help you navigate her preferences, this guide reveals the best gifts for Penny, ensuring you always give her something she’ll love, like, or at least tolerate!
We’ve compiled a comprehensive list of Penny’s gift reactions, from her most loved items to the things she absolutely hates. Understanding these preferences will save you time and resources, allowing you to efficiently raise your friendship level with this sweet villager. Let’s dive into the world of Penny’s presents!
Top Penny Gift Choices: Easy & Effective
For players looking for simple yet effective gifts to give Penny, these items are your best bet. They are relatively easy to acquire early in the game and will elicit positive reactions, helping you quickly build your friendship with her.
Dandelion
Poppy
Emerald
These “Penny Gifts Stardew” players often overlook are actually quite valuable for relationship building! Dandelions are foraged in Spring, Poppies bloom in Summer, and Emeralds can be mined early on. They are all items Penny either likes or loves, making them fantastic, accessible options.
Penny’s Loved Gifts: Maximize Friendship Points
To truly impress Penny and maximize your friendship gains, focus on giving her loved gifts. These items will provide the most friendship points and show her you really care about her tastes.
Poppy
Melon
Diamond
Emerald
Sandfish
Poppyseed Muffin
Red Plate
Roots Platter
Tom Kha Soup
Golden Pumpkin
Magic Rock Candy
Pearl
Prismatic Shard
These loved gifts range in difficulty to obtain. Poppy and Poppyseed Muffins are relatively easy to get, while Diamonds and Prismatic Shards are much rarer, making them extra special gifts for Penny. Dishes like Red Plate, Roots Platter and Tom Kha Soup require cooking, but are worth the effort for the friendship boost.
Penny’s Liked Gifts: Solid Choices for Friendship
If you don’t have access to Penny’s loved gifts, items she likes are still excellent choices. They provide a good amount of friendship points and are often more readily available.
Explore More Gift Options for Penny
Show/Hide Penny’s Liked Gifts
Sweet Pea
Fiddlehead Fern
Fire Quartz
Crocus
Leek
Dandelion
Rainbow Shell
Frozen Tear
Earth Crystal
Milk
Goat Milk
Fairy Rose
Pumpkin
Corn
Cauliflower
Summer Spangle
Sunflower
Bok Choy
Taro Root
Tomato
Beet
Artichoke
Eggplant
Amaranth
Blue Jazz
Tulip
Radish
Yam
Red Cabbage
Potato
Parsnip
Green Bean
Kale
Garlic
Amethyst
Ruby
Jade
Aquamarine
Topaz
Truffle Oil
Triple Shot Espresso
Aged Roe
Juice
Honey
Maple Syrup
Goat Cheese
Duck Mayonnaise
Jelly
Cloth
Coffee
Cheese
Caviar
Pickles
Mayonnaise
Apricot
Pomegranate
Cherry
Apple
Orange
Peach
Pizza
Omelet
Radish Salad
Poi
Pancakes
Plum Pudding
Parsnip Soup
Pepper Poppers
Rhubarb Pie
Pink Cake
Farmer’s Lunch
Lucky Lunch
Maki Roll
Lobster Bisque
Mango Sticky Rice
Trout Soup
Pumpkin Pie
Spicy Eel
Squid Ink Ravioli
Tropical Curry
Rice Pudding
Dish O’ The Sea
Autumn’s Bounty
Hashbrowns
Vegetable Medley
Artichoke Dip
Banana Pudding
Ice Cream
Tortilla
Baked Fish
Super Meal
Blackberry Cobbler
Bean Hotpot
Fiddlehead Risotto
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish Stew
Sashimi
Fried Calamari
Fish Taco
Fried Mushroom
Fried Eel
Salmon Dinner
Fruit Salad
Salad
Pumpkin Soup
Glazed Yams
Bruschetta
Cranberry Candy
Stuffing
Escargot
Crab Cakes
Eggplant Parmesan
Stir Fry
Carp Surprise
Spaghetti
Chocolate Cake
Cheese Cauliflower
Coleslaw
Cookie
Complete Breakfast
Blueberry Tart
Cranberry Sauce
Roasted Hazelnuts
Crispy Bass
Ginger Ale
Chowder
Prehistoric Rib
Prehistoric Handaxe
Dwarf Scroll I
Chipped Amphora
Ancient Drum
Bone Flute
Rare Disc
Chewing Stick
Dried Starfish
Chicken Statue
Dwarf Gadget
Prehistoric Scapula
Prehistoric Tibia
Prehistoric Skull
Dwarvish Helm
Elvish Jewelry
Skeletal Tail
Rusty Spur
Skeletal Hand
Palm Fossil
Glass Shards
Survival Burger
Golden Relic
Ornamental Fan
Golden Mask
Arrowhead
Rusty Spoon
Prehistoric Tool
Rusty Cog
Treasure Chest
Ancient Sword
Trilobite
Nautilus Fossil
Prehistoric Vertebra
Maple Bar
Ancient Seed
Anchor
Ancient Doll
Large Milk
Amphibian Fossil
Life Elixir
Miner’s Treat
Dinosaur Egg
Dinosaur Mayonnaise
Penny likes a wide variety of items, including most gems, cooked dishes, foraged items, and produce. This generous list gives you plenty of options throughout the game, ensuring you always have something suitable to give her.
Neutral Gifts for Penny: Safe but Less Effective
These gifts won’t hurt your friendship with Penny, but they won’t help much either. If you have nothing else, these are acceptable, but aim for liked or loved gifts for better results.
Show/Hide Penny’s Neutral Gifts
Wild Horseradish
Chanterelle
Winter Root
Coral
Daffodil
Magma Cap
Morel
Clam
Crystal Fruit
Hazelnut
Rainbow Shell
Cactus Fruit
Spice Berry
Coconut
Snow Yam
Blackberry
Ginger
Common Mushroom
Wild Plum
Nautilus Shell
Roe
Truffle
Egg
Duck Egg
Tea Leaves
Strawberry
Starfruit
Rhubarb
Sweet Gem Berry
Hot Pepper
Cranberries
Wheat
Ancient Fruit
Blueberry
Banana
Pineapple
Mango
Bread
Fried Egg
Large Egg
Squid Ink
Golden Egg
Ostrich Egg
Most foraged items, fruits, and basic cooked items fall into Penny’s neutral category. While these won’t offend her, they aren’t the most efficient way to build friendship.
Gifts Penny Dislikes: Avoid These to Maintain Friendship
Giving disliked gifts will slightly decrease your friendship with Penny. While not disastrous, consistently giving these items will hinder your progress. Try to avoid these if possible.
Show/Hide Penny’s Disliked Gifts
Spring Onion
Purple Mushroom
Clam
Salmonberry
Oyster
Cave Carrot
Quartz
Red Mushroom
Wool
Duck Feather
Unmilled Rice
Vinegar
Rice
Wheat Flour
Oil
Oak Resin
Pine Tar
Qi Fruit
Walleye
Woodskip
Albacore
Tuna
Tilapia
Void Salmon
Tiger Trout
Mussel
Midnight Squid
Midnight Carp
Blue Discus
Bullhead
Catfish
Super Cucumber
Bream
Chub
Sunfish
Salmon
Scorpion Carp
Blobfish
Lobster
Shad
Red Snapper
Smallmouth Bass
Stingray
Eel
Crayfish
Dorado
Crab
Cockle
Stonefish
Perch
Flounder
Pike
Ghostfish
Red Mullet
Squid
Slimejack
Halibut
Shrimp
Herring
Sea Cucumber
Ice Pip
Sardine
Spook Fish
Sturgeon
Largemouth Bass
Octopus
Lava Eel
Periwinkle
Lingcod
Pufferfish
Lionfish
Rainbow Trout
Anchovy
Algae Soup
Pale Broth
Curiosity Lure
Stepping Stone Path
Fire Opal
Ghost Crystal
Gravel Path
Thunder Egg
Jasper
Quality Retaining Soil
Quality Sprinkler
Treasure Hunter
Radioactive Carp
Radish Seeds
Trap Bobber
Cork Bobber
Spinner
Quality Fertilizer
Iron Bar
Quality Bobber
Helvite
Tree Fertilizer
Gold Bar
Qi Bean
Garlic Seeds
Pyrite
Fairy Stone
Tulip Bulb
Stone
Pumpkin Seeds
Stone Fence
Refined Quartz
Cobblestone Path
Potato Seeds
Kale Seeds
Poppy Seeds
Jagoite
Pomegranate Sapling
Iridium Ore
Pineapple Seeds
Spring Seeds
Void Essence
Hardwood
Pine Cone
Granite
Rhubarb Seeds
Glacierfish
Petrified Slime
Geminite
Tomato Seeds
Fluorapatite
Rice Shoot
Fiber
Pepper Seeds
Esperite
Peach Sapling
Driftwood
Parsnip Seeds
Deluxe Retaining Soil
Weathered Floor
Crystal Floor
Orpiment
Stone Floor
Orange Sapling
Coffee Bean
Opal
Rare Seed
Omni Geode
Kyanite
Wheat Seeds
Jazz Seeds
Rustic Plank Floor
Jamborite
Ocean Stone
Iron Fence
Obsidian
Iridium Sprinkler
Winter Seeds
Iridium Bar
Neptunite
Hops Starter
Nekoite
Hematite
Mutant Carp
Hardwood Fence
Baryte
Sprinkler
Banana Sapling
Grape Starter
Apricot Sapling
Gold Ore
Angler
Glacierfish Jr.
Clay
Star Shards
Cinder Shard
Geode
Straw Floor
Gate
Cauliflower Seeds
Frozen Geode
Tigerseye
Starfruit Seeds
Blueberry Seeds
Field Snack
Sandstone
Fall Seeds
Beet Seeds
Fairy Seeds
Battery Pack
Eggplant Seeds
Basic Fertilizer
Wood Fence
Tea Sapling
Dressed Spinner
Lunarite
Dolomite
Slate
Deluxe Fertilizer
Soapstone
Crystal Path
Solar Essence
Crimsonfish
Limestone
Cranberry Seeds
Lemon Stone
Corn Seeds
Legend
Copper Bar
Lead Bobber
Stone Walkway Floor
Spangle Seeds
Coal
Red Cabbage Seeds
Wood Floor
Cherry Sapling
Celestine
Strawberry Seeds
Cherry Bomb
Calcite
Wood Path
Bomb
Sunflower Seeds
Summer Seeds
Cactus Seeds
Taro Tuber
Brick Floor
Melon Seeds
Bone Fragment
Wood
Bok Choy Seeds
Marble
Maple Seed
Mango Sapling
Bixite
Malachite
Bean Starter
Mahogany Seed
Basic Retaining Soil
Magma Geode
Basalt
Tea Set
Barbed Hook
Mushroom Tree Seed
Artichoke Seeds
Mudstone
Apple Sapling
Ms. Angler
Ancient Seeds
Mixed Seeds
Amaranth Seeds
Mega Bomb
Acorn
Yam Seeds
Alamite
Aerinite
Void Egg
Penny dislikes a wide array of items, particularly fish, certain foraged items, and crafting materials. Pay close attention to this list to avoid accidentally giving her something she won’t appreciate.
Penny’s Hated Gifts: Friendship Fails
These are the worst gifts you can give Penny. Hated gifts will severely damage your friendship level. Absolutely avoid giving Penny any of these items.
Show/Hide Penny’s Hated Gifts
Grape
Sea Urchin
Holly
Rabbit’s Foot
Hops
Mead
Beer
Pale Ale
Sugar
Wine
Carp
Snail
Strange Bun
Seafoam Pudding
Radioactive Ore
Rain Totem
Red Slime Egg
Mummified Frog
Piña Colada
Qi Seasoning
Seaweed
Slime
Monster Musk
Snake Skull
Snake Vertebrae
Soggy Newspaper
Radioactive Bar
Treasure Chest
Torch
Purple Slime Egg
Sap
White Algae
Rotten Plant
Wild Bait
Tiger Slime Egg
Artifact Trove
Joja Cola
Iron Ore
Magic Bait
Fossilized Leg
Mummified Bat
Green Algae
Green Slime Egg
Grass Starter
Hay
Fairy Dust
Explosive Ammo
Magnet
Fossilized Ribs
Fossilized Skull
Fossilized Spine
Flute Block
Drum Block
Broken Glasses
Bug Meat
Dragon Tooth
Copper Ore
Bug Steak
Cookout Kit
Crab Pot
Golden Coconut
Blue Slime Egg
Warp Totem: Island
Warp Totem: Desert
Bat Wing
Warp Totem: Mountains
Warp Totem: Farm
Void Mayonnaise
Warp Totem: Beach
Penny strongly dislikes alcohol, sugar, and many “trash” items or monster drops. These gifts reflect items she finds unpleasant or useless, so steer clear of them when trying to befriend her.
Giving Penny Gifts: A Path to Friendship
Understanding Penny’s gift preferences is crucial for building a strong relationship with her in Stardew Valley. By focusing on her loved and liked gifts, especially easy-to-obtain “penny gifts stardew” like Dandelions and Poppies, you can efficiently increase your friendship level. Avoid disliked and hated gifts to ensure your efforts aren’t undermined. Happy gifting and enjoy your blossoming friendship with Penny!
