Visiting New York City means immersing yourself in a vibrant culture, iconic landmarks, and unforgettable experiences. Naturally, you’ll want to take a piece of the Big Apple home with you. While NYC souvenir shops are ubiquitous, filled with Statue of Liberty miniatures and “I Heart NY” tees, the quality often leaves much to be desired. And let’s not forget the unwritten rule of haggling in stores that rarely display prices, leaving tourists guessing if they’re getting a fair deal on their Ny Gifts New York Ny.
But fear not, savvy souvenir seekers! You can find truly exceptional and authentic ny gifts new york ny that capture the spirit of the city, without the tourist trap hassle. Many of New York City’s esteemed institutions and beloved local businesses offer shipping, bringing the best of NYC directly to your doorstep. Imagine receiving iconic museum relics, gourmet delights from top restaurants, or even a miniature piece of the subway system, all without lugging them in your already stuffed suitcase.
Keep reading to explore over 40 of the finest NYC gifts, perfect for locals, former New Yorkers, and anyone captivated by the magic of the city.
Our Top Picks for NYC Gifts:
Food Gifts
A container of various pasta shapes.
Rubirosa Pasta Sampler
For over a decade, Rubirosa has been a Nolita gem, celebrated for its incredible pizzas and pastas. Praised by Meghan Markle as the “holy grail” of pizza and awarded a Michelin Bib Gourmand in 2012, Rubirosa embodies authentic New York Italian flavor. Even if you missed dining in their cozy space, you can still savor their culinary artistry at home. Their pasta sampler, or a selection of their signature sauces and olive oil, allows you to recreate the Rubirosa experience in your own kitchen, making it a perfect ny gifts new york ny for food lovers.
A bottle of Calabrian chili oil.
Frankies 457 Calabrian Chili Oil
Frankies 457 Spuntino, a Cobble Hill favorite, is a must-visit for its rustic Italian dishes, especially the cavatelli with hot sausage. While experiencing the full menu requires a visit, you can take home a taste of Frankies with their Calabrian chili oil. This luscious, spiced olive oil, often drizzled on their pizzas, is a delicious and versatile condiment. It’s an ideal ny gifts new york ny for anyone who appreciates gourmet pantry staples and a touch of NYC flavor in their cooking.
Two plain bagels stacked on top of each other.
H&H Bagels One Dozen Bagels
Bringing bagels home from NYC is practically a rite of passage. While grabbing a dozen from a local bagel shop before your flight is a budget-friendly option, H&H Bagels offers a guaranteed taste of New York bagel perfection, even if you forget to get them fresh. These iconic bagels are a quintessential ny gifts new york ny, saving you from the disappointment of returning home empty-handed and bagel-less.
A whole cheese pizza in a cardboard box.
Di Fara Pizza Neapolitan Pizzas, 2-pack
Di Fara Pizza, located deep in Brooklyn, is a pilgrimage for pizza aficionados, even for seasoned New Yorkers. Considered by many to be the pinnacle of New York pizza, Di Fara’s pies are a true culinary experience. Treat someone special (or yourself!) to the taste of authentic Brooklyn pizza with this 2-pack. Unboxing these pizzas is like gifting a piece of New York history and flavor, making them exceptional ny gifts new york ny.
A box of ten different hot sauces.
Heatonist Hot Ones Hot Sauce 10-pack, Season 25
For fans of the hit web series “Hot Ones,” Heatonist is the Brooklyn-based hot sauce emporium behind the show’s fiery selections. This 10-pack, featuring sauces from Season 25, offers a thrilling taste experience. Gifting this set is like challenging someone to a flavorful test of New York City citizenship, making it a unique and fiery ny gifts new york ny.
Two raw bone-in rib steaks.
Peter Luger Dry-Aged Bone-in Rib Steaks
Peter Luger Steak House, a Brooklyn institution since the 19th century, is renowned for its old-school charm and exceptional steaks. Securing a reservation can be challenging, but you can skip the wait and bring Peter Luger’s quality home. Their dry-aged bone-in rib steaks, available from their butcher shop, are incredibly high-quality and surprisingly easy to cook to perfection, making it a luxurious ny gifts new york ny for steak enthusiasts.
Subscription boxes of coffee beans.
Sey Coffee Subscription
Start your day with the taste of Brooklyn, wherever you are. Sey Coffee, a celebrated roaster in Bushwick, offers a monthly coffee subscription that delivers freshly roasted, high-quality beans directly to your door. This subscription is a thoughtful ny gifts new york ny for coffee lovers, ensuring a daily reminder of their NYC experience with every brew.
A four-pack of bottled Negronis.
St. Agrestis Negroni, 4-pack
New Yorkers are known for their opinions, especially when it comes to cocktails. St. Agrestis Negronis, bottled in Brooklyn, are a perfect conversation starter. Bring this 4-pack to any gathering and you’re guaranteed to spark debate and enjoyment. These Negronis are a sophisticated and spirited ny gifts new york ny, embodying the city’s vibrant social scene.
Home Goods
A red book cover with an image of a bar interior.
Great Bars of New York City: 30 of Manhattan’s Favorite Storied Drinking Establishments by James and Karl Murray
“Great Bars of New York City” is more than just a guide; it’s a love letter to the city’s iconic bars, the backdrops for countless stories, relationships, and memories. This book is a perfect ny gifts new york ny for anyone who appreciates New York’s rich bar culture, offering a curated tour of 30 legendary Manhattan establishments and the history within their walls.
A black and white photograph of street musicians playing instruments.
Ricky Flores “Congeros” (1984) print
Ricky Flores, a South Bronx-based photojournalist, captures the soul of his borough in his powerful images. While recognized for his 9/11 and Hurricane Sandy coverage, his intimate portraits of everyday Bronx life are equally compelling. This “Congeros” print is a striking piece of art, a perfect ny gifts new york ny for those who appreciate authentic NYC culture beyond the tourist hotspots.
Two blue and white ceramic coffee cups resembling Greek diner cups.
Original NY Coffee Cup, ceramic version, 2-pack
Even miles away from NYC, you can still enjoy your coffee like a true New Yorker. These ceramic versions of the iconic blue and white “Anthora” coffee cups evoke the city’s classic diner culture. This 2-pack is a nostalgic ny gifts new york ny, perfect for anyone who misses the simple pleasure of a New York street cart coffee.
A Staten Island Ferry Christmas ornament.
Staten Island Ferry ornament
For car-free New Yorkers, the Staten Island Ferry is a vital link to the often-overlooked borough. Beyond its practical function, the ferry is also visually striking with its apricot hue. This Staten Island Ferry ornament captures a piece of New York infrastructure and aesthetic, making it a unique and charming ny gifts new york ny, especially for those who appreciate the city’s hidden gems.
A glass vase with a sunflower design.
Monet Sunflowers glass vase
Inspired by Monet’s iconic “Sunflowers” paintings, this glass vase from the Met Museum Store adds a touch of artistic elegance to any home. While sunflowers are a fitting choice, this beautiful vase can hold any bouquet. It’s a sophisticated ny gifts new york ny for art enthusiasts and those who appreciate museum-quality home décor.
A Christmas ornament shaped like NYC library cards.
NYPL Library Card ornament
For bookworms and New York Public Library lovers, this library card-shaped Christmas ornament is a charming and unique gift. Celebrating the joy of reading and the iconic NYPL, it’s a perfect ny gifts new york ny for the literary-minded, reminding them of the city’s intellectual heart.
$15 at New York Public Library Shop
A white ceramic mug with NYC health inspection grades.
Sanitary Inspection Mug
A humorous and quintessentially New York gift, the Sanitary Inspection Mug features the city’s iconic restaurant grade system. Choose between an “A” or “Grade Pending” mug, depending on your giftee’s personality (and perhaps your opinion of them!). This quirky mug is a fun and lighthearted ny gifts new york ny, perfect for those who appreciate NYC’s unique character.
A container of wildflower seed mix with floral illustrations.
NYBG Wonderland Wildflower Seed Mix
Bring the beauty of the New York Botanical Garden home with this Wildflower Seed Mix. Imagine the vibrant colors of the NYBG’s gardens blooming in your own backyard. This seed mix is a thoughtful and eco-friendly ny gifts new york ny, perfect for gardeners and nature lovers who want to cultivate a piece of NYC beauty wherever they are.
A ceramic coaster with the Unisphere design.
Queens Unisphere coaster
The Unisphere, a symbol of the 1964 World’s Fair, still stands proudly in Flushing Meadows, Queens. This coaster captures the iconic globe’s design, allowing you to bring home a piece of Queens history. It’s a stylish and subtle ny gifts new york ny, perfect for those who appreciate mid-century modern design and NYC landmarks.
A soft Christmas ornament of a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich.
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich ornament
The bacon, egg, and cheese – the quintessential New York breakfast sandwich, often simply called a “baconeggncheese” by locals. This ornament celebrates this simple yet iconic culinary staple. For a truly authentic touch, remember to ask for extra black pepper when you order one in NYC! This playful ornament is a delicious ny gifts new york ny, perfect for foodies and NYC breakfast enthusiasts.
A small container of Yafa Bakhoor Sena resins.
Yafa Bakhoor Sena
Yafa Brooklyn brings the aromatic traditions of Yemen to NYC. Bakhoor Sena, a traditional Yemeni incense resin, offers a warm and inviting scent with notes of amber and wood. This exotic and fragrant resin is a unique ny gifts new york ny for those seeking globally-inspired home fragrances and a touch of Brooklyn’s diverse cultural landscape.
Clothing, Bags, and Accessories
A white baseball jersey with the words "Old Jewish Men of New York Meats" on it.
Old Jewish Men of New York Meats Jersey
For those who appreciate NYC humor and a good laugh, the Old Jewish Men of New York Meats Jersey is a playful and quirky gift. This baseball jersey is a conversation starter and a fun ny gifts new york ny, perfect for anyone with a sense of irony and love for NYC’s distinctive personalities.
A blue New York Yankees baseball cap with the MoMA logo on the side.
MoMA NY Yankees 9TWENTY Corduroy adjustable baseball cap
Show your New York pride with a stylish twist. This MoMA-exclusive NY Yankees cap combines classic sports fandom with contemporary design. Made from corduroy and featuring the MoMA logo, it’s a fashionable ny gifts new york ny, even if you’re not a die-hard baseball fan. It’s a sophisticated way to represent NYC style.
A white and green mini tote bag with a rat embroidery.
Shop Rat embroidered mini tote
From Emilia Petrarca’s “Shop Rat” newsletter, celebrating NYC shopping, comes this adorable embroidered mini tote. The “Shop Rat” tote is both practical and charming, featuring a cute rat design. It’s a trendy ny gifts new york ny for fashion-conscious individuals who appreciate unique, city-inspired accessories.
A gold necklace with a figure pendant from Chinatown Ice Cream Factory.
The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory necklace
The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory is a NYC institution, and this necklace pays homage to the beloved shop. Featuring a delicate pendant, this necklace is a sweet and subtle ny gifts new york ny for those who cherish memories of Chinatown and delicious ice cream. Hopefully, it will remind them to try the matcha Oreo flavor on their next visit!
$65 at Chinatown Ice Cream Factory
A grey t-shirt with an "I Heart NY" t-shirt design printed on it.
Paste I Heart NY T-Shirt on a T-shirt
A meta take on the classic “I Heart NY” shirt. This Paste T-shirt features the iconic design printed on another t-shirt, adding a layer of irony and humor. It’s a clever and self-aware ny gifts new york ny for those who appreciate a playful twist on familiar NYC imagery.
A grey t-shirt with a green leaf and the words "NYC Parks".
NYC Parks Leaf T-Shirt
Show your appreciation for NYC’s green spaces with the NYC Parks Leaf T-Shirt. This shirt is a reminder of the city’s surprisingly abundant nature, perfect for dispelling the myth that New York is all concrete and skyscrapers. It’s a subtle and eco-conscious ny gifts new york ny for nature lovers and city dwellers alike.
A red and white oversized golf umbrella with the Nathan's Famous logo.
Nathan’s Famous Green/White Oversized Golf umbrella
Declare your love for Nathan’s Famous hot dogs, even on a rainy day. This oversized golf umbrella, featuring the iconic Nathan’s logo, is a fun and functional gift. Why not let your umbrella signal your frankfurter fervor? It’s a whimsical ny gifts new york ny, perfect for Nathan’s enthusiasts and those who enjoy quirky accessories.
A blue tote bag with the Variety Coffee Roasters logo.
Variety Coffee Tote
Carry your essentials in style with this capacious tote bag from Variety Coffee Roasters, one of NYC’s beloved coffee chains. This sturdy tote is not only practical but also a subtle nod to New York’s coffee culture. It’s a versatile ny gifts new york ny, perfect for coffee aficionados and anyone needing a reliable and stylish everyday bag. Bonus points if you include a bag of Variety coffee beans inside!
$20 at Variety Coffee Roasters
A black canvas bag with a magazine illustration.
Casa Magazines canvas bag
For magazine lovers, Casa Magazines is a pilgrimage site, boasting over 2,000 titles, from mainstream publications to obscure gems. This canvas bag, emblazoned with the Casa Magazines logo, is a badge of honor for print enthusiasts. It’s a unique ny gifts new york ny for magazine aficionados and those who appreciate independent NYC shops.
A small blue Allmansright UltraGrid Kross bag.
Allmansright UltraGrid Kross
Allmansright, a Bronx-based label, proves that NYC fashion isn’t just about high fashion. Their sturdy and ultralight UltraGrid Kross bag is perfect for outdoor adventures and everyday carry. This practical and durable bag is a unique ny gifts new york ny, showcasing the city’s blend of urban style and outdoor functionality.
A white bottle of MRD Cosmetics Ambrosia Eau De Parfum.
MRD Cosmetics Ambrosia Eau De Parfum
Marché Rue Dix, a Crown Heights gem combining a restaurant, boutique, and salon, also offers its own line of cosmetics and skincare. MRD Cosmetics Ambrosia Eau De Parfum is a vibrant fragrance, available alongside their liquid lipsticks and nail polishes. This perfume is a sophisticated ny gifts new york ny, capturing the essence of Brooklyn’s stylish and diverse beauty scene.
Collectibles and More
James Paulius Blockitecture Big Apple Collectors set featuring toy blocks of NYC buildings.
James Paulius Blockitecture Big Apple Collectors set
These Blockitecture Big Apple blocks offer charming, cartoonish recreations of iconic NYC landmarks like the Chrysler Building and One World Trade Center (where this very magazine is created!). This collector’s set is an adorable ny gifts new york ny for design enthusiasts and those who appreciate playful representations of the city skyline.
A yellow NYC taxi toy car in a box.
NYC Taxi Car
The iconic yellow taxi is synonymous with New York City. This NYC Taxi Car toy is a classic souvenir, a miniature version of the vehicles that navigate the city streets. It’s a nostalgic ny gifts new york ny, perfect for kids and adults who want a piece of NYC transportation history. And unlike a real NYC taxi, this one is guaranteed not to take away your old man (unless your old man is a very small city rat!).
A miniature Wall Street Bull sculpture.
Wall Street Bull Sculpture
The Charging Bull statue is a Wall Street icon, symbolizing financial optimism. This miniature Wall Street Bull Sculpture allows you to own a piece of this powerful imagery, without the crowds of tourists vying for photos. It’s a symbolic ny gifts new york ny, perfect for finance professionals or anyone inspired by New York’s financial district.
An NYC toy subway train set.
MTA Motorized Subway Train set
Even if you opted for ride-sharing during your NYC visit, you can still celebrate the city’s subway system with this MTA Motorized Subway Train set. This toy train is a fun and interactive ny gifts new york ny, perfect for kids and train enthusiasts, and a playful reminder of New York’s underground world. No one needs to know you avoided the real thing!
Enamel pins from the Museum of the Moving Image.
Museum of the Moving Image enamel pin
Declare your cinephile status with these enamel pins from the Museum of the Moving Image. These pins are a subtle yet stylish ny gifts new york ny for film buffs, allowing them to showcase their passion for cinema and their appreciation for NYC’s cultural institutions.
$12 at Museum of the Moving Image
A snow globe featuring the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the NYC skyline.
The Met New York Snow Globe
If your NYC trip lacked snow, create your own winter wonderland with The Met New York Snow Globe. This charming snow globe features the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the city skyline, offering a perpetual snowfall scene. It’s a classic and elegant ny gifts new york ny, perfect for art lovers and those who appreciate a touch of winter magic, regardless of the season.
A red keychain with the words "Books Are Magic Cougar".
Books Are Magic Cougar keychain
From the beloved Brooklyn bookstore Books Are Magic, this Cougar keychain is the store’s “least-friendly” offering, adding a touch of humor to your keys. It’s a quirky and fun ny gifts new york ny for book lovers and those who appreciate the wit of independent bookstores.
A Rockaway Beach magnet featuring a beach scene.
Rockaway Beach magnet
Don’t forget that New York City has beaches! This Rockaway Beach magnet from the New York Transit Museum is a sunny reminder of NYC’s coastal escapes. It’s a simple and affordable ny gifts new york ny, perfect for beach lovers and those who want to remember a different side of New York.
A green miniature NYC trash can pen holder.
ONLY NY DSNY Trash Can pen holder
Even NYC trash cans can be chic, in a uniquely New York way. This ONLY NY DSNY Trash Can pen holder is a playful and ironic ny gifts new york ny, celebrating the city’s everyday objects with a touch of design flair. It’s perfect for those who appreciate urban aesthetics and quirky desk accessories.
A blue enamel pigeon pin from Joe Coffee.
Joe Coffee New York Pigeon enamel pin
Pigeons, often called “sky rats,” are an undeniable part of the New York City experience. This Joe Coffee New York Pigeon enamel pin embraces the city’s avian residents with a touch of humor. It’s a fun and quirky ny gifts new york ny for coffee lovers and those who appreciate the city’s less-refined charms. Just remember, don’t call them sky rats to their face!
A red "Coming Soon" branded lighter.
Coming Soon lighter
The Coming Soon lighter is a subtle indicator that you visited the trendy downtown furniture and art destination. Even if you didn’t splurge on vintage furniture, this lighter is a cool and affordable souvenir. It’s a stylish ny gifts new york ny for design aficionados and those who appreciate the cutting-edge aesthetic of downtown NYC.
