After a lighthearted query on Instagram about whether a demanding day warrants wine or bourbon, the overwhelming response in favor of bourbon was quite telling. It seems many share a strong affinity for this spirit. Inspired by this informal consensus and as a delightful change of pace from my usual gift guide endeavors, I’ve curated a dedicated Bourbon Gifts guide.
Bourbon’s popularity isn’t a fleeting trend; it’s been enjoying a sustained surge for decades. It’s always a perfect time to explore and appreciate quality bourbon.
A significant advantage of gifting bourbon is its longevity compared to wine at a similar price point. This makes it a particularly thoughtful and enduring present for hosts, holiday gatherings, or anyone who appreciates a good drink.
Bourbon bottles on a wooden shelf
While I’m not a seasoned liquor aficionado myself, my partner Jon, a true bourbon enthusiast, has significantly broadened my appreciation over the past decade. He modestly downplays the “connoisseur” label, simply stating, “I’m just someone who likes bourbon.” However, his deep knowledge of fermentation, vanilla notes, oak barrels, aging processes, char levels, and our collection of various ice cube shapes suggests otherwise. His expertise is invaluable in creating this bourbon gifts guide.
In fact, to be transparent, this guide is truly a collaborative effort. Without Jon’s insights, it would likely miss the mark entirely.
Therefore, I proudly present:
My Expertly Curated Bourbon Gifts Guide for Every Bourbon Lover
For convenient purchasing, I’ve linked to Drizly, a platform that allows price comparison and liquor delivery. Supporting your local independent liquor stores is also highly encouraged.
Bourbon Gifts for the Unsure Palate: A Crowd-Pleaser
Maker’s Mark: This is the quintessential entry-level craft bourbon that consistently delights. Its smooth, approachable flavor profile ensures it will be well-received by almost anyone. As a bourbon gift, Maker’s Mark is a safe bet, embodying quality and tradition without being overly challenging for those newer to bourbon.
Elevated Bourbon Gifts: Stepping Up the Sophistication
Basil Hayden Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: For a slightly more refined bourbon gift, Basil Hayden offers a lighter body and higher rye content, resulting in a subtly spicy and elegant taste. It’s an excellent choice for those who savor their bourbon neat or on the rocks and appreciate a more nuanced flavor profile.
Bourbon Gifts to Share: Hoping for a Taste
Four Roses Small Batch Select bourbon bottle on a table
Four Roses Small Batch Select: Crafted from six of Four Roses’ ten unique bourbon recipes, this Small Batch Select is remarkably smooth, subtly sweet, and offers exceptional value. Gifting this bourbon hints at sharing, but remember, etiquette dictates the recipient decides when and if to open a gifted bottle. Patience is key!
Bourbon Gifts for Cocktail Connoisseurs: Mixology Mastery
Woodford Reserve: Known for its slightly sweet profile and rich character, Woodford Reserve is a versatile bourbon gift perfect for crafting refined mixed drinks. Its balanced flavor shines through in cocktails, elevating classics like a simple Ginger Bourbon with Fever Tree Ginger Beer.
Buffalo Trace: An exceptional value for an 8-year-aged bourbon, Buffalo Trace is a highly regarded choice for bourbon gifts. It’s praised for its quality and versatility. Beyond sipping, it excels in cocktails, notably Manhattans. Consider pairing it with Carpano Antica sweet vermouth, bitters, and maraschino cherries for a complete DIY Manhattan bourbon gift set.
Impressive Bourbon Gifts: Father-in-Law Approved (and Beyond)
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked bourbon bottle on a bar
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked: This bourbon gift is designed to impress. The Double Oaked expression takes the classic Woodford Reserve and matures it in a second, deeply toasted barrel, resulting in enhanced notes of caramel, vanilla, and maple. Its memorable impression makes it a standout bourbon gift, appreciated by all palates, regardless of gender.
Display-Worthy Bourbon Gifts: Bottled Elegance
Blanton’s Single Barrel: For the bourbon enthusiast who appreciates presentation as much as taste, Blanton’s Single Barrel is an ideal bourbon gift. Its smooth, refined character and iconic bottle, topped with a collectible horse and jockey stopper, exude sophistication. This bourbon gift is both a pleasure to drink and a striking addition to any home bar.
Bourbon Gifts for the Curious Mind: Factoid-Fueled Enjoyment
Booker’s: As a bourbon gift for the detail-oriented drinker, Booker’s offers a rich backstory and bold flavor. This small-batch bourbon, from the pioneers of the small-batch concept, is released in batches, each with a unique story detailing barrel origins and aging specifics. For instance, Booker’s Storyteller Batch provides precise percentages from different warehouse floors, offering fascinating cocktail party conversation starters.
Bourbon Gifts Beyond Kentucky: Expanding Horizons
Widow Jane 10 Year Straight Bourbon bottle
Widow Jane 10 Year Straight Bourbon: Encourage exploration with this bourbon gift. Widow Jane 10 Year Straight Bourbon, crafted in Brooklyn, New York, offers a departure from traditional Kentucky bourbons. This small-batch, well-regarded bourbon is surprisingly approachable and a favorite among locals, making it a unique and thoughtful bourbon gift.
Celebratory Bourbon Gifts: Toasting Milestones
Maker’s Mark 46 Cask Strength: With “46” in its name, this bourbon gift can carry a symbolic meaning. Maker’s Mark 46 Cask Strength offers a bolder, more intense expression of the classic Maker’s Mark, perfect for marking significant occasions.
Premium Bourbon Gifts: For the Finest Moments
Recommendations courtesy of bourbon aficionado Adam Jacob Miller
EH Taylor Single Barrel or EH Taylor Small Batch: “Simply exquisite. While it may initially present a slight alcohol aroma, it mellows beautifully, revealing a truly delicious bourbon experience.” These EH Taylor expressions are top-tier bourbon gifts for those who appreciate refined taste.
Stagg Jr.: “Barrel proof and undeniably potent, yet surprisingly approachable despite its high proof. At 132.6 proof, it’s not for the faint of heart, but for those who appreciate intensity, Stagg Jr. delivers a remarkable bourbon experience.” A truly special bourbon gift for the adventurous palate.
Life is too short to save the good stuff. If your budget allows, indulging in exceptional bourbon is always a worthwhile treat. You’ve earned it.
Are there any essential bourbons missing from this guide? Share your bourbon wisdom in the comments below!
Important Reminder: Always be mindful that not all adults consume alcohol. Many valid reasons exist for abstaining, and thoughtful non-alcoholic alternatives are readily available as excellent gifts.
