Like many bourbon enthusiasts, my liquor store visits often turn into treasure hunts. A few months before the world changed, during a routine furniture shopping trip, I decided to explore a liquor store I don’t usually frequent, always on the lookout for something unique for the blog. That’s when I stumbled upon something special: the Maker’s Mark “Generations of Proof” Gift Set.
Initially, my eyes were caught by a complete Rhetoric Bourbon Collection, prominently displayed. While impressive, the $2600 price tag was a bit steep for an impromptu purchase. However, it fueled my curiosity to explore the bourbon aisle further, hoping to find something more budget-friendly yet equally intriguing. And I wasn’t disappointed.
There it was, on the top shelf, a Maker’s Mark collection from the previous year (copyright 2019) – the “Generations of Proof” Gift Set. As a long-time admirer of Maker’s Mark, one of my first bourbon loves and a standout wheated bourbon, this collection immediately caught my attention. Featuring cask-strength versions of Maker’s Mark, Maker’s 46, and a Maker’s Private Select, it seemed like a fantastic find. I decided to bring it home, filed it away in my closet, and, admittedly, almost forgot about it.
Recently, with the announcement of this year’s limited edition, Maker’s 46 Cask Strength, my memory was jogged. Having previously enjoyed Maker’s 46 Cask Strength, especially bottles acquired directly from the Kentucky distillery and Private Selects using Maker’s 46 staves, the “Generations of Proof” set resurfaced in my mind. The timing felt perfect to revisit this collection.
Upon closer inspection, I realized the brilliance of this gift set. It showcases cask strength expressions representing each generation of Samuels family leadership at Maker’s Mark: Maker’s Mark for Bill Samuels Sr., Maker’s 46 for Bill Samuels Jr., and Private Select for Rob Samuels. This thoughtful concept elevates it beyond a simple Bourbon Gift Set, making it a tribute to the brand’s legacy.
Having already reviewed Maker’s Cask Strength and Maker’s 46 Cask Strength individually, I’ll focus on the tasting notes for the Rob Samuels Private Select from this set.
Maker’s Mark Private Select: Rob Samuels (from Maker’s Mark “Generations of Proof” Gift Set)
Purchase Details: Acquired for $84.99 (for the three 375ml bottle gift set) at Lakeville Liquors, Lakeville, MN. This pricing makes it an accessible premium bourbon gift set for enthusiasts.
Price per Drink (50 mL): Approximately $3.78, highlighting its value within the premium bourbon category.
Specifications: Bottled at 55.1% ABV. The unique stave combination includes: Two Seared French Cuvee, four Roasted French Mocha, and four Toasted French Spice. This bespoke stave selection is what sets Private Select apart and contributes to its distinctive flavor profile, making it a standout in any bourbon gift set.
Tasting Experience:
Nose: The aroma is immediately inviting, dominated by rich butterscotch notes, quickly followed by warm spices of cinnamon and nutmeg. There’s a subtle, refreshing hint of mint that adds complexity. This initial nosing promises a rich and layered tasting experience.
Mouth: The palate is warm and sweet, mirroring the nose with pronounced butterscotch, cinnamon, and nutmeg flavors. As it develops, notes of oak, ginger, and almond emerge, adding depth and a pleasant dryness that balances the initial sweetness. The cask strength presentation ensures a robust and full-bodied flavor.
Finish: The finish is warm and lingers for a medium length, leaving a pleasant aftertaste of toffee, cocoa powder, oak, and almond. This evolving finish makes each sip a journey, characteristic of a high-quality bourbon gift set component.
Conclusion:
The Maker’s Mark “Generations of Proof” Bourbon Gift Set is more than just a collection of whiskies; it’s a curated experience that tells the story of a brand through its different expressions. The Rob Samuels Private Select, in particular, offers a unique and delightful tasting experience. For anyone seeking a thoughtful and impressive bourbon gift set, especially for a Maker’s Mark aficionado or someone looking to explore cask strength bourbons, this set is an excellent choice. Its presentation, the story it tells, and the quality of the bourbon inside make it a standout option in the crowded bourbon gift market.
