Spending time in New York City inevitably leads you to the ubiquitous “New York City Gifts” shops. While the allure of a miniature Statue of Liberty or an “I Heart NY” t-shirt is understandable, the street-level versions often lack quality. These stores also frequently avoid displaying prices, creating an environment where haggling is almost a necessity to avoid overpaying.
However, acquiring memorable souvenirs of your New York experience doesn’t have to involve questionable quality or price negotiations. Numerous reputable New York City institutions offer high-quality collectibles that can be shipped directly to your home. Imagine receiving relics from the city’s renowned museums, gourmet foods from its celebrated restaurants, or even models of the iconic subway cars. The best part? You can skip the hassle of squeezing them into your luggage.
Discover over 40 of the finest Nyc Gifts, perfect for locals, former residents, and anyone captivated by the magic of the Big Apple, all available online.
Jump to:
Our Top Picks for NYC Gifts:
Food Gifts
Rubirosa Pasta Sampler: Taste of Nolita at Home
For more than a decade, Rubirosa has been celebrated for its exceptional pizzas and pasta dishes, attracting celebrity fans like Meghan Markle and earning a Bib Gourmand from Michelin in 2012. If you missed dining at their cozy Nolita restaurant, the Rubirosa Pasta Sampler brings the taste of NYC directly to your kitchen. This NYC gift is perfect for food lovers who want to recreate authentic Italian flavors at home. It’s also a great way to remember a favorite NYC culinary experience.
Frankies 457 Calabrian Chili Oil: Spice Up Your Pantry with Brooklyn Flavor
A visit to Cobble Hill’s Frankies 457 is essential to fully appreciate their menu, especially the cavatelli with hot sausage and sage butter. However, you can capture a piece of their culinary magic with Frankies 457 Calabrian Chili Oil. This luscious, spiced olive oil, often drizzled on their pizzas next door, is a delightful NYC food gift. It provides a taste of Brooklyn’s best, perfect for drizzling on pizzas, pasta, or simply enjoying with bread.
H&H Bagels One Dozen Bagels: The Authentic NYC Bagel Experience
While grabbing bagels from a local shop before your flight is an option, H&H Bagels deliver the quintessential New York bagel experience directly to your door. These are genuine NYC bagels, perfect for gifting or enjoying a taste of the city at home. For anyone missing that authentic New York breakfast, this NYC gift is a guaranteed hit.
Di Fara Pizza Neapolitan Pizzas, 2-pack: Brooklyn’s Legendary Pizza Delivered
Di Fara Pizza, nestled deep in Brooklyn, is a pilgrimage for pizza aficionados, often missed even by New Yorkers. Di Fara Neapolitan Pizzas, 2-pack, allows you to share this treasure with someone special. This is more than just pizza; it’s a culinary experience, making it an exceptional NYC gift for those who appreciate authentic, handcrafted food.
box of 10 different hot sauces
Heatonist Hot Ones Hot Sauce 10-pack, Season 25: Spice Up Life with Brooklyn Hot Sauces
“Hot Ones” fans know Heatonist, the Brooklyn hot sauce emporium, is behind the show’s fiery selections. The Heatonist Hot Ones Hot Sauce 10-pack, Season 25, delivers the same heat experienced by celebrity guests. Gift this NYC experience to spice lovers and challenge them to a true “rite of passage” into New York City’s fiery food scene. This NYC gift is perfect for adventurous eaters and fans of the popular web series.
Peter Luger Dry-Aged Bone-in Rib Steaks: Legendary Steakhouse Experience at Home
Securing a reservation at Peter Luger, a steakhouse icon since the 19th century, can be challenging. Peter Luger Dry-Aged Bone-in Rib Steaks offer a solution. These high-quality steaks from their butcher shop bring the legendary Peter Luger experience home. Even for novice cooks, these steaks are incredibly flavorful and a luxurious NYC gift for steak enthusiasts.
Sey Coffee Subscription: Brooklyn Brews Delivered Monthly
A Sey Coffee Subscription brings the taste of Brooklyn’s vibrant Bushwick neighborhood to your doorstep every month. Sey Coffee, a renowned roaster, ensures a constant supply of exceptional coffee. This NYC gift is ideal for coffee aficionados, providing a regular reminder of New York’s specialty coffee scene. It’s a thoughtful and practical present for anyone who appreciates high-quality coffee.
four bottles of Negroni in a pack
St. Agrestis Negroni, 4-pack: Spark Conversation with Bottled Cocktails
New Yorkers are known for their opinions, especially when it comes to bars and drinks. St. Agrestis Negroni, 4-pack, is a conversation starter. This NYC gift, featuring a divisive yet beloved cocktail, is guaranteed to liven up any gathering. Bring these bottled Negronis to your next party and watch the debates begin!
Home Goods
red book with picture of a bar on the cover
Great Bars of New York City: A Literary Toast to Manhattan’s Storied Drinking Spots
“Great Bars of New York City” by James and Karl Murray is a heartfelt tribute to New York’s iconic bars and the countless stories they hold. This book is a love letter to the city’s vibrant bar scene and the memories created within them. For book lovers and bar enthusiasts, this NYC gift is a sophisticated and nostalgic choice, perfect for coffee tables or personal libraries.
photograph of people playing instruments on the street
Ricky Flores “Congeros” (1984) Print: Bronx Life Captured in Art
Ricky Flores, a South Bronx-based photojournalist, is celebrated for his impactful work, including award-winning coverage of 9/11 and Hurricane Sandy. However, his intimate portraits of everyday life in the Bronx are equally compelling. The Ricky Flores “Congeros” (1984) print offers a glimpse into the heart of the Bronx. This NYC gift is perfect for art lovers and those who appreciate authentic, street-level perspectives of New York City life.
blue and white greek style coffee cups
Original NY Coffee Cup, ceramic version, 2-pack: Street Cart Coffee at Home
Even after returning home, you can still enjoy your coffee with the iconic New York street cart vibe. The Original NY Coffee Cup, ceramic version, 2-pack, brings the classic blue and white design into your kitchen. This NYC gift is a nostalgic and functional piece of New York City culture, perfect for everyday use or as a decorative reminder of your trip.
ornament of the NY Staten Island ferry
Staten Island Ferry Ornament: A Touch of Nautical New York Charm
For car-less New Yorkers, the Staten Island Ferry is the gateway to the often-overlooked borough. The Staten Island Ferry ornament captures the beauty of this apricot-colored vessel. This NYC gift is a charming and unique keepsake, especially for those who appreciate New York’s maritime character or have a fondness for Staten Island. It’s a subtle yet elegant reminder of the city.
Monet Sunflowers Glass Vase: Artistic Elegance from The Met
Inspired by Monet’s iconic sunflowers, the Monet Sunflowers glass vase brings a touch of artistic flair to any home. Available at The Met Museum Store, this vase is beautiful even without sunflowers. This NYC gift is perfect for art enthusiasts and those who appreciate museum-quality home décor. It’s an elegant and sophisticated reminder of New York’s cultural richness.
Ornament of NYC Public library cards
NYPL Library Card Ornament: Literary Charm for the Holidays
“Having fun isn’t hard when you’ve got a library card,” and the NYPL Library Card ornament brings that sentiment to your holiday décor. This ornament, shaped like a classic New York Public Library card, is a unique and thoughtful NYC gift for bookworms and library lovers. It’s a charming way to celebrate literacy and the iconic NYPL.
$15 at New York Public Library Shop
Sanitary Inspection Mug: A Humorous Nod to NYC Dining
The Sanitary Inspection Mug offers a playful take on New York City’s restaurant grading system. Choose between an “A” or “Grade Pending” mug, depending on your giftee’s personality and sense of humor. This NYC gift is a quirky and fun conversation starter, perfect for those who appreciate the unique aspects of NYC culture.
container showing illustrations of flowers and
NYBG Wonderland Wildflower Seed Mix: Bring the Botanical Garden Home
Capture the beauty of the New York Botanical Garden with the NYBG Wonderland Wildflower Seed Mix. This seed mix allows you to cultivate a piece of the Garden’s splendor in your own backyard. This NYC gift is perfect for gardeners and nature lovers, offering a lasting and beautiful reminder of the city’s green spaces.
Queens Unisphere Coaster: World’s Fair Icon for Your Coffee Table
The Unisphere, a symbol of the 1964 World’s Fair, has graced Flushing Meadows, Queens, for decades. The Queens Unisphere coaster brings this iconic structure to your home. Even if you missed a photo op at the Unisphere, this NYC gift allows you to bring a piece of Queens history home with you. It’s a stylish and functional souvenir.
bacon, egg and cheese bagel soft ornament.
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich Ornament: NYC Breakfast Icon
The bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich, or “baconeggncheese,” is a New York breakfast staple, celebrated for its simple perfection. The Bacon, Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich ornament immortalizes this classic. This NYC gift is a fun and quirky ornament, perfect for foodies and anyone who loves a good NYC breakfast. Hot tip: add extra black pepper for the full experience!
Yafa Bakhoor Sena: Exotic Aromas from Yemen via Brooklyn
Yafa Bakhoor Sena is an aromatic resin, a traditional Yemeni incense with warm notes of amber and wood. This incense, available from Yafa Brooklyn, brings exotic scents to your home. This NYC gift is for those who appreciate unique fragrances and global cultural experiences. It adds a touch of Brooklyn’s diverse cultural landscape to your home.
Clothing, Bags, and Accessories
Old Jewish Men of New York Meats Jersey: A Playful NYC Tribute Tee
The Old Jewish Men of New York Meats Jersey is a humorous and quirky tribute to New York City. This baseball jersey is a fun and unexpected NYC gift, perfect for those with a playful sense of style and an appreciation for NYC’s unique character. Let’s go… Meats! This shirt is sure to get a chuckle.
blue New York Yankee hat with MoMA logo on the side
MoMA NY Yankees 9TWENTY Corduroy Adjustable Baseball Cap: Stylish Fan Gear
The MoMA NY Yankees 9TWENTY Corduroy adjustable baseball cap is a Yankees cap that transcends typical sports apparel. Featuring the MoMA logo, this cap is stylish enough for even non-sports fans. This NYC gift is a fashionable and subtle way to show New York pride, blending sports heritage with museum-worthy design. Perfect for anyone wanting a stylish NYC accessory.
white and green tote with rat illustration
Shop Rat Embroidered Mini Tote: Chic and Playful NYC Style
From Emilia Petrarca of the Shop Rat newsletter, the Shop Rat embroidered mini tote is brand new and perfectly captures NYC’s chic and playful spirit. This tote is a stylish and functional NYC gift for fashion-forward individuals. Plus, the embroidered rat is undeniably cute! It’s a trendy and unique accessory that reflects the city’s vibrant shopping scene.
necklace with gold figure ornament
The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory Necklace: Sweet Style Statement
Hopefully, you visited the Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory and tried the matcha Oreo ice cream. If not, The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory necklace is a stylish reminder to do so next time. This necklace is a unique and fashionable NYC gift, perfect for jewelry lovers and fans of this iconic NYC institution. It’s a sweet style statement and a conversation starter.
$65 at Chinatown Ice Cream Factory
grey t shirt showing an image of a white
Paste I Heart NY T-Shirt on a T-shirt: Meta NYC Pride
For a meta take on NYC pride, the Paste I Heart NY T-Shirt on a T-shirt is a fun and ironic choice. This t-shirt features the iconic “I Heart NY” logo printed on another t-shirt graphic. This NYC gift is perfect for those who appreciate clever and self-aware fashion. It’s a humorous and unique way to show love for New York.
grey t shirt with green leaf and
NYC Parks Leaf T-Shirt: Nature in the City Apparel
For those who appreciate the city’s green spaces, the NYC Parks Leaf T-Shirt is a perfect choice. This t-shirt subtly celebrates the natural beauty found within New York City’s parks. This NYC gift is ideal for nature enthusiasts and anyone who loves spending time in NYC’s parks. It’s a comfortable and understated way to show appreciation for urban nature.
Nathan’s Famous Green/White Oversized Golf Umbrella: Frankfurter Fan Fashion
Why not express your love for frankfurters with your next umbrella? The Nathan’s Famous Green/White Oversized Golf umbrella is a fun and quirky accessory. This oversized umbrella is a unique and humorous NYC gift for hot dog lovers and those who appreciate quirky style. It’s sure to turn heads on a rainy day.
Variety Coffee Tote: Carry Your Essentials with Coffee Style
The Variety Coffee Tote, from one of New York’s best coffee chains, is a spacious and stylish bag. This tote is a practical and fashionable NYC gift for coffee lovers. It’s perfect for everyday errands, travel, or carrying your favorite books and coffee beans. Plus, it might just qualify as a “personal item” on your next flight, especially with a treat for the gate agent!
$20 at Variety Coffee Roasters
Casa Magazines Canvas Bag: For the Magazine Maven
Casa Magazines, a print magazine mecca with over 2,000 titles, is a must-visit for magazine lovers. The Casa Magazines canvas bag celebrates this unique NYC spot. This canvas bag is an ideal NYC gift for magazine enthusiasts and those who appreciate independent bookstores. It’s a durable and stylish way to carry your favorite reads and support a beloved NYC institution.
Allmansright UltraGrid Kross: Bronx-Made Adventure Gear
Allmansright, a Bronx-based label, proves that NYC fashion is not just about high fashion. The Allmansright UltraGrid Kross is a sturdy, ultralight stash bag perfect for outdoor adventures. This NYC gift is for the adventurous spirit and those who appreciate durable, locally made gear. It’s a practical and stylish reminder of New York’s diverse creative scene.
MRD Cosmetics Ambrosia Eau De Parfum: Crown Heights Fragrance Find
Marché Rue Dix, a Crown Heights gem, is a restaurant, boutique, and salon offering MRD Cosmetics Ambrosia Eau De Parfum. This fragrance, along with other cosmetics and skincare, is available à la carte. This NYC gift is perfect for fragrance lovers seeking unique, locally sourced perfumes. It captures the essence of Brooklyn’s vibrant beauty scene.
Collectibles and More
toy blocks of New York City buildings and landscape
James Paulius Blockitecture Big Apple Collectors Set: Build Your Own NYC Skyline
The James Paulius Blockitecture Big Apple Collectors set features charmingly cartoonish yet adorable recreations of iconic NYC buildings like the Chrysler Building and One World Trade Center. This NYC gift is a delightful and creative collectible, perfect for architecture enthusiasts and those who love building toys. It’s a fun way to recreate the NYC skyline at home.
NYC Taxi Car: Iconic Yellow Cab in Miniature
The NYC Taxi Car toy brings the iconic yellow cab to a smaller scale. This toy taxi is a classic NYC gift, perfect for kids and collectors alike. It’s a fun and recognizable symbol of New York City, sure to evoke memories of navigating the city streets. Just be sure it won’t “take away your old man” unless he’s rat-sized!
Wall Street Bull Sculpture: Financial District Icon, Minus the Crowds
The Wall Street Bull Sculpture captures the Charging Bull icon of the Financial District, without the usual crowds. This miniature bull is a powerful NYC gift for those interested in finance or New York City landmarks. It’s a sophisticated and symbolic piece, perfect for desks or shelves. Finally, you can appreciate the bull without waiting in line to cradle its… well, you know.
MTA Motorized Subway Train Set: NYC Transit Fun at Home
Even if you relied on ride-sharing during your visit, the MTA Motorized Subway Train set lets you celebrate New York’s subway system. This toy train set is a fun NYC gift for kids and train enthusiasts. It’s a playful reminder of the city’s complex transit system, whether you actually rode the subway or not. No one needs to know about those Ubers!
Museum of the Moving Image Enamel Pin: Film Buff Flair
The Museum of the Moving Image enamel pin is a subtle yet stylish way to declare your love for cinema. This pin is a perfect NYC gift for film buffs and museum visitors. It’s a discreet way to show your appreciation for film and the iconic Museum of the Moving Image. Tell everyone you’re a film buff, without saying a word.
$12 at Museum of the Moving Image
globe of the New York City Metropolitan museum of art with the city landscape behind it.
The Met New York Snow Globe: Winter Wonderland in a Globe
If you wished for snow during your NYC visit, The Met New York Snow Globe delivers a perpetual winter wonderland. Featuring the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the city skyline, this snow globe is a classic and beautiful NYC gift. It’s a timeless keepsake, perfect for anyone who loves New York and the magic of snow globes.
Books Are Magic Cougar Keychain: A Playful Bookstore Souvenir
From the beloved Books Are Magic bookstore, the Books Are Magic Cougar keychain offers a touch of playful bookstore charm. This keychain is a fun and quirky NYC gift for book lovers and fans of independent bookstores. It’s the friendliest bookstore’s “least-friendly” keychain, adding a touch of humor to your keys.
Image may contain: Advertisement, Poster, and Person
Rockaway Beach Magnet: Beach Day Memories from NYC
Don’t forget, New York City has beaches! The Rockaway Beach magnet serves as a colorful reminder of NYC’s coastal side. This magnet is a simple and affordable NYC gift, perfect for beach lovers and those who enjoyed exploring NYC’s outer boroughs. It’s a cheerful reminder of sunny days in New York.
ONLY NY DSNY Trash Can Pen Holder: Unexpectedly Chic Desk Accessory
The ONLY NY DSNY Trash Can pen holder proves that even New York City trash cans can be stylish. This pen holder is a quirky and functional NYC gift for those who appreciate unique desk accessories and NYC design. It’s a conversation-starting piece that adds a touch of unexpected NYC chic to any workspace.
blue Joe Coffee brand pigeon pin
Joe Coffee New York Pigeon Enamel Pin: Embrace the NYC Pigeon
The Joe Coffee New York Pigeon enamel pin playfully embraces the city’s ubiquitous pigeons. This enamel pin is a cute and quirky NYC gift for coffee lovers and those with a fondness for NYC’s “sky rats.” It’s a lighthearted and humorous way to remember your time in the city. Just don’t call them sky rats… unless you’re being affectionate.
Coming Soon Lighter: Downtown Cool in Your Pocket
The Coming Soon lighter is a souvenir from the trendy downtown furniture and art destination, Coming Soon New York. This lighter is a cool and minimalist NYC gift, perfect for design enthusiasts and those who appreciate unique finds. It’s a subtle nod to downtown NYC’s trendy scene, even if your budget didn’t stretch to the furniture.
