Building friendships is key to thriving in Stardew Valley, and Caroline is one villager you’ll definitely want to befriend. Born on Winter 7th, Caroline, who runs the Tea Shop with her own tea leaves, is more than just a shopkeeper; she’s a warm and intriguing character. Giving gifts is one of the most effective ways to increase your friendship with Caroline. To help you navigate her preferences, this guide provides a comprehensive list of the best gifts for Caroline in Stardew Valley, ensuring you always give her something she’ll appreciate.
Caroline’s Most Loved Gifts
To truly impress Caroline and maximize your friendship points, these are the gifts to aim for. These items will trigger the most positive reaction and significantly boost your relationship.
Rabbit’s Foot
Summer Spangle
Fish Taco
Tropical Curry
Golden Pumpkin
Magic Rock Candy
Pearl
Prismatic Shard
These loved gifts are Caroline’s absolute favorites and are guaranteed to earn you a significant boost in friendship. While some, like Prismatic Shard and Rabbit’s Foot, are rarer, others such as Summer Spangle, Fish Taco and Tropical Curry are more accessible, especially if you’re focusing on farming and cooking.
Gifts Caroline Likes
If loved gifts are harder to come by, or you’re looking for more readily available options to give Caroline gifts regularly, these “liked” gifts are excellent choices. They still provide a good amount of friendship points and are much easier to obtain in Stardew Valley.
Rainbow Shell
Wild Horseradish
Earth Crystal
Crocus
Sweet Pea
Fiddlehead Fern
Frozen Tear
Daffodil
Fire Quartz
Sunflower
Cauliflower
Bok Choy
Taro Root
Tea Leaves
Tomato
Beet
Artichoke
Corn
Blue Jazz
Pumpkin
Tulip
Potato
Eggplant
Garlic
Yam
Parsnip
Kale
Radish
Red Cabbage
Green Bean
Fairy Rose
Diamond
Amethyst
Jade
Topaz
Aquamarine
Ruby
Emerald
Truffle Oil
Triple Shot Espresso
Aged Roe
Honey
Juice
Pale Ale
Caviar
Beer
Jelly
Wine
Mead
Cloth
Pickles
Goat Cheese
Cheese
Coffee
Maple Syrup
Orange
Apple
Peach
Apricot
Pomegranate
Cherry
Salad
Salmon Dinner
Coleslaw
Chocolate Cake
Stir Fry
Crab Cakes
Radish Salad
Dish O’ The Sea
Lobster Bisque
Pancakes
Lucky Lunch
Maki Roll
Mango Sticky Rice
Sashimi
Pumpkin Soup
Shrimp Cocktail
Parsnip Soup
Spicy Eel
Red Plate
Cranberry Sauce
Ice Cream
Cookie
Pepper Poppers
Poi
Hashbrowns
Pale Broth
Rhubarb Pie
Poppyseed Muffin
Pink Cake
Escargot
Cheese Cauliflower
Eggplant Parmesan
Ginger Ale
Spaghetti
Rice Pudding
Pizza
Fruit Salad
Squid Ink Ravioli
Roasted Hazelnuts
Crispy Bass
Fried Mushroom
Cranberry Candy
Fried Eel
Stuffing
Fried Calamari
Complete Breakfast
Fish Stew
Plum Pudding
Roots Platter
Chowder
Fiddlehead Risotto
Glazed Yams
Omelet
Farmer’s Lunch
Carp Surprise
Bruschetta
Super Meal
Bean Hotpot
Pumpkin Pie
Vegetable Medley
Blueberry Tart
Trout Soup
Artichoke Dip
Banana Pudding
Baked Fish
Tortilla
Blackberry Cobbler
Tom Kha Soup
Algae Soup
Autumn’s Bounty
Piña Colada
Miner’s Treat
Treasure Chest
Life Elixir
Maple Bar
Survival Burger
Dinosaur Mayonnaise
Caroline “liked” gifts are a diverse bunch, ranging from foraged items and minerals to cooked dishes and artisan goods. Notice a pattern? Caroline has a penchant for flowers, gems, cooked dishes, and certain crops. Utilizing items like Daffodils, Sweet Peas, or even readily farmed crops such as Cauliflower or Tomatoes can be a sustainable way to build your friendship with her.
Neutral Gifts for Caroline
These gifts won’t increase or decrease your friendship with Caroline. They are safe to give if you have them on hand but won’t help you progress your relationship.
Rainbow Shell
Nautilus Shell
Cactus Fruit
Blackberry
Coconut
Spice Berry
Crystal Fruit
Coral
Wild Plum
Grape
Clam
Egg
Roe
Truffle
Milk
Duck Feather
Wool
Duck Egg
Goat Milk
Hops
Wheat
Sweet Gem Berry
Strawberry
Starfruit
Rhubarb
Melon
Ancient Fruit
Blueberry
Hot Pepper
Cranberries
Banana
Pineapple
Mango
Bread
Fried Egg
Squid Ink
Large Milk
Large Egg
Golden Egg
Ostrich Egg
Caroline’s neutral gifts are a mixed bag of foraged items, animal products, and fruits. While these won’t hurt your relationship, focusing on liked or loved items will be more efficient for friendship building.
Gifts Caroline Dislikes
Giving Caroline disliked gifts will negatively impact your friendship. It’s best to avoid these items unless you accidentally give them.
Morel
Oyster
Ginger
Magma Cap
Purple Mushroom
Spring Onion
Holly
Winter Root
Wild Horseradish
Common Mushroom
Dandelion
Clam
Chanterelle
Cave Carrot
Hazelnut
Snow Yam
Leek
Amaranth
Unmilled Rice
Wheat Flour
Duck Mayonnaise
Vinegar
Mayonnaise
Oil
Rice
Pine Tar
Oak Resin
Qi Fruit
Sunfish
Super Cucumber
Walleye
Void Salmon
Tiger Trout
Tilapia
Albacore
Sturgeon
Tuna
Anchovy
Lava Eel
Largemouth Bass
Lionfish
Blue Discus
Stingray
Blobfish
Lingcod
Lobster
Bream
Woodskip
Bullhead
Midnight Squid
Midnight Carp
Crayfish
Crab
Mussel
Spook Fish
Ice Pip
Octopus
Slimejack
Perch
Herring
Periwinkle
Smallmouth Bass
Scorpion Carp
Sea Cucumber
Sardine
Shad
Squid
Pike
Salmon
Eel
Cockle
Pufferfish
Dorado
Shrimp
Ghostfish
Catfish
Sandfish
Red Mullet
Red Snapper
Chub
Stonefish
Rainbow Trout
Halibut
Flounder
Rare Seed
Coal
Spangle Seeds
Rusty Spoon
Fall Seeds
Gate
Quality Retaining Soil
Quality Sprinkler
Radioactive Carp
Radish Seeds
Rare Disc
Golden Relic
Rustic Plank Floor
Quality Fertilizer
Quality Bobber
Taro Tuber
Elvish Jewelry
Cherry Sapling
Deluxe Fertilizer
Refined Quartz
Wood
Sunflower Seeds
Brick Floor
Red Cabbage Seeds
Qi Bean
Rhubarb Seeds
Iron Fence
Helvite
Pyrite
Rice Shoot
Skeletal Tail
Tea Sapling
Hardwood Fence
Pumpkin Seeds
Grape Starter
Glass Shards
Gold Ore
Rusty Cog
Glacierfish
Prehistoric Vertebra
Geode
Prehistoric Tool
Frozen Geode
Prehistoric Tibia
Field Snack
Prehistoric Skull
Fairy Seeds
Soapstone
Prehistoric Scapula
Rusty Spur
Dried Starfish
Prehistoric Rib
Wheat Seeds
Prehistoric Handaxe
Curiosity Lure
Potato Seeds
Cork Bobber
Poppy Seeds
Pomegranate Sapling
Pineapple Seeds
Wood Fence
Starfruit Seeds
Chicken Statue
Basic Fertilizer
Spring Seeds
Banana Sapling
Cactus Seeds
Apple Sapling
Tea Set
Sandstone
Battery Pack
Pine Cone
Baryte
Petrified Slime
Arrowhead
Jazz Seeds
Stone Floor
Jamborite
Kale Seeds
Skeletal Hand
Jasper
Iridium Sprinkler
Jagoite
Iridium Bar
Iron Bar
Slate
Iridium Ore
Hops Starter
Pepper Seeds
Summer Seeds
Trilobite
Peach Sapling
Hematite
Parsnip Seeds
Tulip Bulb
Palm Fossil
Hardwood
Thunder Egg
Gravel Path
Orpiment
Granite
Ornamental Fan
Golden Mask
Orange Sapling
Gold Bar
Opal
Glacierfish Jr.
Omni Geode
Void Essence
Tigerseye
Ghost Crystal
Ocean Stone
Geminite
Obsidian
Garlic Seeds
Tomato Seeds
Fluorapatite
Neptunite
Fire Opal
Nekoite
Fiber
Nautilus Fossil
Fairy Stone
Mutant Carp
Esperite
Dwarf Scroll I
Eggplant Seeds
Weathered Floor
Dwarvish Helm
Solar Essence
Dwarf Gadget
Mushroom Tree Seed
Driftwood
Mudstone
Dressed Spinner
Ms. Angler
Dolomite
Trap Bobber
Deluxe Retaining Soil
Mixed Seeds
Winter Seeds
Crystal Floor
Crystal Path
Spinner
Crimsonfish
Strawberry Seeds
Cranberry Seeds
Melon Seeds
Corn Seeds
Mega Bomb
Copper Bar
Ancient Doll
Coffee Bean
Anchor
Cobblestone Path
Amaranth Seeds
Clay
Mango Sapling
Cinder Shard
Malachite
Chipped Amphora
Wood Floor
Chewing Stick
Wood Path
Cherry Bomb
Sprinkler
Celestine
Magma Geode
Cauliflower Seeds
Treasure Hunter
Calcite
Lunarite
Bone Fragment
Bomb
Blueberry Seeds
Star Shards
Bone Flute
Stone
Bok Choy Seeds
Stepping Stone Path
Beet Seeds
Stone Fence
Bixite
Limestone
Bean Starter
Lemon Stone
Basic Retaining Soil
Legend
Basalt
Tree Fertilizer
Barbed Hook
Lead Bobber
Artichoke Seeds
Ancient Sword
Apricot Sapling
Ancient Seed
Angler
Stone Walkway Floor
Ancient Seeds
Kyanite
Ancient Drum
Straw Floor
Marble
Maple Seed
Amphibian Fossil
Mahogany Seed
Acorn
Yam Seeds
Aerinite
Alamite
Void Egg
Dinosaur Egg
Caroline’s disliked gifts are quite extensive, including most forage items (except flowers), fish, cooked dishes that aren’t desserts, crafting materials, seeds, and fertilizers. This suggests she’s not a fan of the “rougher” aspects of farm life and prefers more refined or aesthetically pleasing items.
Hated Gifts for Caroline
Giving these gifts to Caroline will result in the largest negative friendship penalty. Absolutely avoid these items if you want to befriend her!
Salmonberry
Sea Urchin
Red Mushroom
Quartz
Poppy
Sugar
Carp
Snail
Strange Bun
Seafoam Pudding
Snake Skull
Snake Vertebrae
Soggy Newspaper
Tiger Slime Egg
Seaweed
Treasure Chest
Slime
Torch
Artifact Trove
Sap
Green Slime Egg
Wild Bait
Red Slime Egg
Green Algae
Blue Slime Egg
Radioactive Bar
Radioactive Ore
Rotten Plant
Grass Starter
Joja Cola
Iron Ore
Magnet
Magic Bait
Mummified Bat
Monster Musk
Mummified Frog
White Algae
Purple Slime Egg
Hay
Golden Coconut
Bug Meat
Fossilized Leg
Fossilized Skull
Fossilized Ribs
Qi Seasoning
Broken Glasses
Rain Totem
Flute Block
Fairy Dust
Fossilized Spine
Copper Ore
Bug Steak
Cookout Kit
Crab Pot
Dragon Tooth
Drum Block
Explosive Ammo
Warp Totem: Beach
Warp Totem: Mountains
Bat Wing
Warp Totem: Farm
Warp Totem: Island
Void Mayonnaise
Warp Totem: Desert
Caroline’s hated gifts are largely trash items, ores, monster loot, and low-quality foraged items like Salmonberry and Poppy. Giving her these items will severely damage your friendship, so steer clear! Notably, while she likes Daffodils and Sweet Peas, she hates Poppies, showing a more specific preference within flowers.
Boosting Friendship with Caroline: Key Takeaways
To maximize your friendship gains with Caroline in Stardew Valley, focus on giving her Loved and Liked gifts. Summer Spangles and Daffodils are easily accessible liked gifts, especially in their respective seasons. For loved gifts, consider cooking Fish Taco or Tropical Curry, or saving up those rare Rabbit’s Feet and Prismatic Shards for special occasions. Avoid giving her disliked or hated items, particularly trash, ores, and monster parts, to ensure your friendship blossoms!
