After a lighthearted question on Instagram about whether a long day warrants wine or bourbon, the overwhelming response for bourbon truly highlighted its popularity. It wasn’t even a formal poll, but the strong opinions about this spirit were clear.
This enthusiasm inspired a dedicated bourbon gift guide, a fun detour from my usual gift recommendations.
Bourbon isn’t just having a moment; it’s been enjoying decades of appreciation. It’s always a great time to discover or share something new to savor.
A fantastic benefit of gifting bourbon is its longevity compared to wine at a similar price point. This makes it a thoughtful and lasting present for hosts, holiday visits, or anyone who enjoys a good drink.
Maker's Mark Bourbon Bottle
While I’m not a heavy liquor drinker myself, my partner Jon, a true bourbon enthusiast, introduced me to this world ten years ago.
He might modestly downplay the title of “connoisseur,” but his knowledge of fermentation, vanilla notes, oak barrels, aging processes, and char levels is undeniable. Plus, our freezer is consistently stocked with seven different ice cube shapes – that’s connoisseur level in my book!
So, consider this guide a collaboration, heavily reliant on Jon’s expertise. Without him, it would definitely miss the mark.
Let’s dive into the bourbon gift guide!
Links provided are to Drizly for price comparison and convenience. Supporting your local independent liquor store is always encouraged.
The Go-To Bourbon Gift When You’re Unsure of Their Taste: Maker’s Mark
Maker’s Mark is the quintessential entry-level craft bourbon. Its smooth, approachable flavor profile makes it universally appealing. You can be confident that Maker’s Mark will be well-received by any bourbon drinker, making it a safe and excellent choice when you’re unsure of their specific preferences. It’s a classic for a reason and a perfect introduction to the world of bourbon gifts.
Elevate Your Gift: Basil Hayden Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
For a slightly more sophisticated bourbon gift, consider Basil Hayden Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey. This bourbon offers a more refined taste, making it a superb option for those who prefer to enjoy their bourbon neat or on the rocks. Basil Hayden is known for its lighter body and subtle spice, appealing to those who appreciate nuance in their spirits. It’s a step up from entry-level options and a thoughtful choice for a more discerning bourbon enthusiast.
The Bourbon Gift You Hope They’ll Open and Share: Four Roses Small Batch Select
Four Roses Small Batch Select is the ideal bourbon to bring as a gift when you’re subtly hoping to partake in the enjoyment. Crafted from six of Four Roses’ ten distinct bourbon recipes, it’s known for its smooth and sweet character, all while remaining under $50. This makes it a fantastic value for its quality and taste. Remember, while gifting a bottle is generous, etiquette suggests not pressuring your host to open it immediately.
Four Roses Small Batch Select Bourbon Bottle
Bourbons for Exquisite Mixed Drinks: Woodford Reserve & Buffalo Trace
For bourbon drinkers who appreciate a well-crafted cocktail, Woodford Reserve and Buffalo Trace are excellent choices.
Woodford Reserve, with its slightly sweet profile, is incredibly versatile for mixing. A simple yet delightful combination is Bourbon and Ginger Beer, especially with Fever Tree Ginger Beer.
Buffalo Trace, an 8-year aged bourbon at a great price, is a favorite for Manhattans. To create a thoughtful DIY Manhattan gift set, pair Buffalo Trace with an affordable sweet vermouth like Carpano Antica, along with some bitters and maraschino cherries. These bourbons elevate mixed drinks, moving beyond basic college concoctions to sophisticated, flavorful cocktails.
Impress Your Father-in-Law (or Anyone Special): Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
To truly impress, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked is the bourbon gift to choose. Its rich, complex flavor profile is unforgettable. My dad still raves about this bourbon after Jon shared it with him, hence the category name. While the name is a bit of a joke, the quality is no laughing matter – this bourbon is universally loved, regardless of gender.
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Bourbon Bottle
For the Displaying Drinker: Blanton’s Single Barrel
Blanton’s Single Barrel is the perfect gift for the bourbon lover who appreciates both quality and presentation. This exceptionally smooth bourbon is highly regarded and will definitely earn you points with those who are particular about their drink – even down to the ice-to-water ratio. Beyond the exquisite bourbon inside, the bottle itself is a work of art, making it a prized addition to any home bar. Aim to find it under $200, as prices can vary significantly.
For the Bourbon Facticionado: Booker’s
Booker’s is tailored for the bourbon enthusiast who loves to delve into the details and share intriguing facts. Coming from the pioneers of small-batch bourbon, each Booker’s batch has its own unique story, meticulously documented.
For example, Booker’s Storyteller Batch (2023-24) details the barrel storage breakdown by warehouse and floor level. These details offer excellent cocktail party conversation starters and appeal to the bourbon geek who appreciates the nuances and history behind their drink. It’s a gift that engages both the palate and the mind.
Venture Beyond Kentucky: Widow Jane 10 Year Straight Bourbon
Widow Jane 10 Year Straight Bourbon is a fantastic bourbon gift for those interested in exploring beyond traditional Kentucky bourbons. This small-batch, well-crafted bourbon, surprisingly affordable for its quality, is made in Red Hook, Brooklyn. It’s a local favorite, including in our own home and many Brooklyn liquor stores. Gifting Widow Jane is a nod to craft distilleries and diverse American bourbon making.
Widow Jane 10 Year Straight Bourbon Bottle
A Politically Charged Toast (Optional): Maker’s Mark 46 Cask Strength
Maker’s Mark 46 Cask Strength offers a playful, politically themed gifting option. The “46” in the name subtly references the US presidency, making it a unique gift for those with a political sense of humor. Whether toasting to political outcomes or simply enjoying a robust cask strength bourbon, it’s a memorable and conversation-starting gift.
Bourbon Gifts for Any Occasion: EH Taylor & Stagg Jr.
Guest recommendations from bourbon aficionado Adam Jacob Miller
For truly special occasions, or simply for those who appreciate top-tier bourbon, EH Taylor Single Barrel or the more accessible EH Taylor Small Batch are exceptional bourbon gifts. EH Taylor is described as “simply delicious,” offering a smooth and refined drinking experience despite a slight initial alcohol aroma.
Stagg Jr., a barrel-proof bourbon, is for those who prefer a bolder taste. While strong at 132.6 proof, it’s surprisingly approachable, not as intensely overpowering as the high proof might suggest. As a comparison, Maker’s Mark is 90 proof.
These high-end bourbons are perfect for celebrating significant milestones or simply embracing the “don’t save the good stuff” philosophy. If your budget allows, these are gifts that will undoubtedly be appreciated and savored.
Did we miss your favorite bourbon gift? Share your recommendations in the comments below!
Important Note: Remember that not everyone drinks alcohol. Non-alcoholic options like Curious Elixirs are also thoughtful gifts.
